I'm unsure where exactly I stand on Eric Gill, though I abhor the knee-jerk, uninformed media and consumer reaction that is now monolithic, reactionary and always ill-informed. Let's do the good stuff first. Eric was a medievalist but not in the academic sense. He was a living proponent of an agrarian ideal based on art as craft and work, opposing the mass production of the industrial age which he felt had stripped dignity from the working man, peasant to artisan. He was a typeface designer, engraver and sculptor whose work is, to my mind, exquisitely simple, forthright and honest. He wore a smock, knee-length socks, no underwear and a traditional stonemason's paper hat at work, with other ancient headpieces at rest. Fanatically Catholic, he stopped for regular prayer during the day and compline at night, with a chapel in many of the residences he built or restored. He believed industry is interested in things made and art is interested in the making of things. His thinking sat squarely with distributism: the idea that property and the means of production should be widely held rather than concentrated in the hands of capital or the state.
On the many locations where he lived, Gill's aim was to build a guild-like community of fellow craftists, all taking pride in their toil, labour as the point and financial reward less so. He was fantastically successful at this, living in England, the remote mountains of Wales, and spells in Switzerland. He attracted all sorts of odd bods and eccentrics inspired by his manner of living-work. He had three daughters and an adopted son, and a truly loving and tolerant wife despite his consensually accepted affairs. There is something almost prepossessing about the portrait that emerges: a man who chose his life and was, by and large, gloriously happy with his choices. He had beliefs, he followed them, and was both popular and loved by family and friends. I've often wondered about the essence of the agrarian lifestyle versus exploring the cosmos. In short, are we designed to toil in the fields, grow our own food and model our lives around this planet, or are we destined for the stars? It might be a bit of both.
Now the darker side. Eric Gill was interested in everything and had a lively, super-curious mind. He would converse with anyone about anything, no matter how small, if it was sincere and up for debate. For example he examined his own semen versus his dog's under a microscope and shared this with a very well-to-do lady friend and semi-lover. How did he get the dog semen? Exactly. He never let anything get in the way of his experimental mind, but that mind also pushed boundaries: incestuous relations with a sister, as well as his daughters, and experiments that included the dog. The author Fiona MacCarthy doesn't document with granularity the lifelong sexual escapades recorded in his diary entries, but there's enough to get a sense of a huge sexual appetite without knowing the full scope. His incestuous pursuits appear to have been treated, at least by those involved, as an extension of familial affection rather than something forced. His daughters married, held no lasting animosity, and one later left her own child to spend time in the Welsh monastery building he once lived in. These are not the actions of damaged children in the conventional sense. How did he do it? I don't know, but it seems they accepted it as experimentation or an extension of love, despite being far beyond the norms. The other shoe is that it was a secret. Nobody else knew, despite the many visitors and live-in guests, and it sat completely at odds with his zealous Catholicism. While he used confession for affairs, I don't believe he told the priests the full scope of his activities. There is something recondite about the gap between the public Catholic and the private experimenter.
I don't condone his sexual engagements, but I am of the belief that if there are no injured parties and all participants are at ease with the matter, it is not my business, however repellent some elements may be. We are all different. What I took from the book is that Eric Gill had a phenomenal ability to compartmentalise. This part of his life was locked down without deep introspection, a very human trait, albeit to a lesser and still maddening degree in most of us. He was sedulous in his craft and in the building of his communities; the same diligence seems to have been applied to keeping certain compartments sealed.
A fascinating book, terrific artistic pursuits, but it leaves you a little queasy. Eric Gill is the sculptor of Ariel and Prospero outside the BBC Broadcasting House, which was smashed by a livid protester a few years back. You can bet they hadn't read this book and were guided by the mainstream narrative that now disavows Eric Gill while concealing that 250 thousand underage girls have been raped by mainly Pakistani grooming gangs. Literally hiding their crimes from mainstream audiences. They disgust me even more.
One last comment. The book cover is one of the worst designs I've ever come across with and would not have had Eric's approval. I dabbled with the image above on Grok to improve it a little.


